Assume Love (TM): How to have a happier marriage without waiting for your spouse to change (daisy logo)

April 8, 2017

What's Reasonable to Ask of Your Husband or Wife?

Back before my first husband died and I finally caught on to my real part in our relationship, this was an area where I made lots of mistakes. And as I moved on and got to know lots of recently divorced or separated folks my age, I discovered I was far from alone in not seeing this issue very clearly.

What Happens When You Don't Ask for What You Want?

If you don't ask for what you want, you're not likely to get it. Whether it's to be rid of your responsibility to pick up toilet paper today, to take a vacation trip this summer, or to try a new sexual position, if you don't ask, the chances are high you'll do without. Unfortunately, the chances are also quite high you'll blame your spouse. And not just today, but for a year or two or three after your divorce if too many of these unfulfilled wishes pile up.

And they are likely to pile up, just because you're blaming your spouse for your unhappiness, because this changes who you are and how you interact with this most important person in your life.

And all this could be happening even though your spouse wants to ask you for the same thing but is avoiding the possibility of rejection.

Ah, Yes. Rejection. How Can You Avoid Rejection When You Want Something?

You can't. Not entirely. But you can probably avoid the sting of rejection if you ask without expectation or insult. Here's an example of an insulting way to ask your spouse to pick up the toilet paper you were supposed to buy today:

Have you ever noticed how often I run errands for you, just to make your day easier? You never do that for me. But today would be a good day to start. We need toilet paper, and we need it before your parents arrive here at 7 pm.

Here's another insulting way to ask for something you want, robbing your spouse of any pleasure in doing something extra nice for you:

Just this freakin' once, could we please try something new in bed? I promise I won't ask again for at least a year.

But there are subtler ways to insult your spouse while asking for what you want, including any hint that you distrust their desire to be good to you if it's in their power to do so:

I don't imagine it's in our budget or anything you'd want to do, but I sure would like to see the California coast again.

And then there's expecting that just because you want it, your spouse can and must offer it up, which is both insulting to your spouse and unnecessarily damaging to your own enjoyment of your relationship:

You'll pick up Bob and Eleanor at the airport when they come, and I'll get their room ready.

Here's how to minimize the chances of rejection:

Are you available to pick up toilet paper before your parents get here tonight?
I read about something really interesting to try in bed. Would tonight after the kids are asleep be a good time to tell you about it while I give you a massage?
I've been daydreaming a lot lately about seeing the California coast again. I love it so much. Can we make some time this weekend to talk about how we could make it happen?
Bob and Eleanor are coming next Tuesday. Can we make a short to-do list today and decide who's doing what?

Now there's room for delighting each other and room to discuss Third Alternatives if you disagree.

And what if the answer is still 'no'?

The best marriages are safe places, our shelter from the rest of the world. We must be able to say 'no' to our spouse to feel that safety. And so must your wife or husband.

But when you have just one spouse to ask, 'no' can be pretty hard to take. For me, it wasn't until after my first husband's sudden death at age 35 that I began to understand what to do when the answer is 'no.' I learned quickly, because the answer is always 'no' from a dead husband, and while you're grieving (and getting used to being a single parent with a lot less income) is no time to be looking for a 'yes' man.

  • I learned there are ways to get things done that neither of you can do or wants to do. Move your prescriptions to a pharmacy that delivers. Pay (or barter with) a neighbor who likes cooking to cook enough for both families. Get TaskRabbit to deliver that needed toilet paper or ask someone at work going out for lunch to pick some up in exchange for help next week with a project. Use paper plates if you're the cook and hoping for help with the dishes that you don't get.
  • Learn new skills. If a new sexual position is more than your spouse is ready for now, master some new bedroom skills that don't require permission or find a great book that explains and shows some of your options.
  • Become more adventurous. I had no idea how many things I wanted to do that I insisted my first husband do with me. When he said 'no,' I was off the hook for figuring out the logistics and handling the awkwardness of being a first-timer. If you want to see the coast and there's not enough money for a family vacation, figure out how to get there inexpensively and on your own. Couch surfing? House sitting? A week of working for a dog walking service there? Join an online discussion forum with folks who live there, so you'll have company when you get there?
  • Make new friends, the sort who might actually enjoy picking up your guests at the airport or getting a room ready for them. Some won't even want you to do anything in return other than have an occasional conversation (something that takes a lot more effort for anyone without a spouse).

After years of finding my way through all of these solutions to getting what I wanted after my husband was dead and the answer was always 'no,' I met my second husband. We don't actually agree on much. Fortunately, I don't expect him to agree, because there's always a way to get what I want that doesn't leave me resentful or insulting.

If there's one thing I've learned from this journey, it's that the one thing to expect from marriage is love. That's the reason we marry. We all crave it. And all of our other expectations seem to push away love, that one thing we need most.

March 26, 2017

Takeoffs and Takeovers: Scary Marriage

If you want to enjoy being married, it's a good idea not to frighten your spouse.

There are two big things that frighten people about relationships. Some are frightened by one or the other, some by both. And if you're not frightened by the same one, it's pretty easy to accidentally frighten the person at the center of your life.


One of these two fears is you taking off. They're scared of being abandoned, rejected by someone they love and respect.

Before marriage, they may keep multiple relationships going, just to minimize the feared pain of being dumped by the one they really want (which was probably you, the one they married). Or they might have clung pretty tightly: "Will I see you again?" "Tomorrow?" "Where do you see this relationship going?" "We're soul mates, I will never leave you."

Who tends to harbor this fear? Anyone can, but it's even more likely if your spouse had a parent walk out or die early in life or an unreliable parent or if he or she depends on you for income or physical care.

This is definitely the one that affects me. Unfortunately, the fear tends to make me do things to reduce my fear that will frighten a partner with the other fear, and the way they handle that fear will increase my fear of a takeoff. What a mess! I'm really glad that my second husband and I are both aware of these fears and how easy it is to set them off.


The other big fear some partners have is you taking over, dictating what they wear, who they see, where they live, which dreams they pursue, what they're responsible for and whether they're handling it well enough.

They might expect most marriages eventually fail and be okay with divorce. This might even be their escape hatch in case they feel suffocated.

Who feels this fear? Anyone can, but those who grew up with a helicopter parent or a parent living vicariously through them and their talents or an unpredictable parent are even more likely to.

So, how do you scare your partner?

Danger: Prepare for Takeoff

If your husband or wife fears being left, you scare them when you start spending more hours at work or with friends or on your hobby or less time on sex or the things you normally do to show your love -- anything that hints of a lower priority for your marriage -- without enough reassurance that you still value your relationship.

Then there's the supreme takeoff, the one where you both abandon them and stay in their life, taunting them, by cheating on them. Hints of infidelity are probably even scarier, even if there's nothing actually going on, if you're married to someone fearful of abandonment.

Danger: Brace for Hostile Takeover

If you want to scare someone afraid of being suffocated or penned in by a relationship, tell them your expectations of what marriage is all about as if they come from a rule book instead of your imagination and limited experience. Try to "fix their flaws." Overbook their time without their consent. Accept a job in another city and announce the impending family move as a fait accompli.

Or, at the scarier end of the spectrum, blame your obnoxious or physically threatening behavior on drugs or alcohol or your religion, as if you have no control over it and no way to protect them from it.

Accidentally Scary

Of course, these two fears are big enough that you can trigger either of them with even an off-the-cuff comment. I just told a friend what I'm writing about today, and she said, "Oh, I think I just scared my husband earlier today. We passed a painting of a house in a gallery window. I recognized it immediately. It's my 2025 vision, the very house I'd love to buy down the road. He said, 'It's not my vision.'"

Which fear did she trigger? It could have been either one. If he's afraid she'll take off, he might imagine she means to move there without him (thinking to himself, whether accurately or inaccurately "surely she knows it's not a place I would ever like"). If he fears a takeover, he might imagine she's actually got an 8-year plan to uproot his life and force him into a house he doesn't want to live in, rather than a goal to afford such a place and find one they both would enjoy.

So, what happens next? Nothing, I hope, if she didn't trigger very much of either sort of fear. Or if he will Assume Love when he feels fear well up from something as simple as a mention of a dream house. Or if he's confident in their ability to Find Third Alternatives to whatever they disagree on.

If he sees this as a warning sign that he could be dumped, either an attempt to either hang onto to her more tightly (which she's likely to notice) or to begin preparing himself for life without her (which she's not likely to notice until it's too late).

And if he sees it as a warning sign that she's taking over his life, now that he's retired and can't use his profession as a protective wall? Well, then he might start imagining life after divorce or start subtly scuttling her efforts to continue building her career or to be able to buy such a house.

How to Dial Back Your Scariness

If you're angry at the wonderful person you married, you may not feel like reducing the fear you're triggering. But if you're feeling loving or if scaring your spouse doesn't seem likely to improve whatever's got you angry, here are some things you can do.

  • When you change your routine in a way that gives you less time with your spouse who is fearful of Takeoffs, announce the change and the reason for it and provide some reassurance that you still value him or her.
  • When you announce a goal that might be misconstrued as a step away from your marriage, announce your intention for your marriage at the same time, and don't tell yourself those vows years ago ought to be all the assurance anyone should need.
  • Don't say you don't care to a Takeoff-fearful spouse.
  • When you want something that affects your joint lifestyle with a spouse who's scared by the possibility of a Takeover, use the language of Third Alternatives to share your wish: tell them what it is about the change that appeals to you and let them know your goal remains a lifestyle that suits both of you.
  • Before you make a suggestion for how your Takeover-fearful spouse can become a better person or a better partner, remind them of what you already appreciate about them and ask if they'd like any input on whatever you see as the goal of your suggestion.
  • Don't nag or insult a Takeover-fearful spouse.
  • And, of course, do whatever it takes to make sure you don't cheat, threaten, manipulate, or harm your spouse: walk away from temptation, quit drinking, quit drugging, and stick to the loving core of your religion not the fine print justifications.

It's not about being a good or bad person. It's about creating an environment in which you can enjoy being married, because the benefits of a happy marriage are huge.

February 28, 2017

The #1 Most Important Step in Settling a Disagreement with Your Spouse

When you're married to someone you love -- or even someone you want to love again -- there is only one way to handle a disagreement over anything important. That is to find a Third Alternative, one you both like enough to happily walk away from your initial great idea that didn't fly well with your husband or wife.

The first step in finding a Third Alternative is the most important step. If you skip it, you may never find your Third Alternative. Or you may find one but lose out on the great feelings of finding it as a team.

What is this critical first step? It's jumping the net. Forgetting the competition to put yourself on the same side as your spouse. It's letting go of your first alternative before you even know what your shared Third Alternative will be. It's having confidence in your ability to give that man or woman at the center of your life the moon and the stars without giving up anything you need or crave.

It's announcing that you do, indeed want what he or she is asking for, and you're willing to work to get it. The only difference between this and caving in is that you also announce you're unwilling to use the particular strategy your spouse proposes (his or her first alternative) to get it. But you want the outcome it's intended to bring.

If you start asking questions about the specs for a Third Alternative before you jump the net, it's a volley. You're hitting a ball over the net to your mate. And your mate is going to hit it back. You won't learn the truth about what really matters to him or her. Instead, you'll get a sales pitch for an alternative you already know you don't like.

If you start proposing Third Alternatives before you jump the net and admit you'll only accept a new option that gives both of you everything you need and nothing you can't tolerate, they'll get shot down. And you won't know why or how to propose a better one.

That's because we humans do a great job of making up stories designed to change your thinking rather than reveal ours. But a successful Third Alternative -- not to mention a satisfying marriage -- requires that you learn what really matters to the person you married.

So before you work on specs or propose alternatives, jump the net. Make sure your beloved knows you're now on his or her side, not just your side. Because a successful Third Alternative satisfies you both and protects you both. And they're out there, waiting to make your life together even more satisfying than a life where all you get is what you ask for.

January 17, 2017

Do I Forgive My Boyfriend for Hitting Me?

I just had to answer a question on Quora today. Someone had been hit by a normally gentle and kind boyfriend who "just snapped." She claimed she'd done nothing wrong, but she thought it might have happened because she was studying with a male student. And she made it clear she wanted to be told it's not a problem if it happens just once.

I could not tell her that, so I wrote this, and I wanted to share it with you, too.

It may be just once, but let's get clear about it. Anyone who hits you when you do something wrong is a really bad choice for a partner. Our home should be our safe place from the dangers of the world. Sharing it with someone who feels justified in deciding what's right and wrong for you and making it unsafe whenever he chooses is NOT a healthy life choice.

If he did it because he "just snapped" it means he sometimes cannot control the way he acts. He can feel one way and behave another. This is just as dangerous but often treatable. If he gets it treated, then "just once" isn't a problem. For him, it's a blessing, for you a few awful moments in a long life.

If he does nothing about it, he doesn't care enough about your safety to live with.

How to treat it? That depends on the cause. Drug and alcohol use can cause this. The treatment then is to learn to live without drugs and alcohol. A brain tumor can cause this. The treatment then involves a team of physicians. Alzheimers can cause this, but there's no real treatment yet; you'll need others to protect you. More often, a lack of skills causes it. I like the CompassionPower approach of Dr. Steven Stosny, but there are also plenty of anger management classes available and psychologists who can teach this one-on-one.

The problem with just ignoring it is that no one who really loves you wants to hurt you. This means that every time he hurts you, he'll likely invent an explanation for doing it other than lack of self-control. Usually those explanations make you out to be a bad person and make it less and less likely over time that he'll do anything about his very serious problem.

Your own explanations for it will make you out to be a better person, a person who doesn't hurt the ones you love and who forgives. A relationship in which the two partners look down on each other is quickly drained of love and becomes just a dangerous living arrangement for them and especially for their children.

So my answer is to forgive him after he takes some action other than promises to prevent it from happening again. Or leave him before it can happen again. And make sure you have family or friends around you for a few days just in case he snaps again when you break it off.

December 10, 2016

Going to the Store to Buy Gum

We lost John Glenn this week. So did his wife, Annie. What a pair!

Although she had a really difficult time handling daily life on her own until someone finally gave her a cure for her communication-crippling stutter at age 53, Annie sent her husband Glenn off on at least 149 combat missions in two wars, numerous high-altitude test flights, the first ever American orbit around the earth when he was 40 years old and into space again at 77.

Every time, he would say, "I'm just going down to the corner store to get a pack of gum."

And every time, she would reply, "Don't be long."

A great private ritual to set aside their fear of the very real risk of losing each other.

Working in careers where the invitations to cheat on his wife were frequent and many of his colleagues (combat pilots, test pilots, astronauts, Senators, and Presidential candidates) took advantage of such invitations as a way to shake off the constant stress of these roles, John Glenn spoke up for marital fidelity as essential to the role of American hero and pointed the media to the good works of his wife Annie as even more important than his own.

Their two children were very, very fortunate to have such role models for how to love.

I enjoyed these two articles in the Washington Post about their marriage. I hope you will, too.

Annie Glenn: 'When I called John, he cried. People just couldn't believe that I could really talk.' by Travis M. Andrews

John Glenn survived space and celebrity -- and still had a great marriage by Lily Koppel

And in explanation of my recent absence from this blog: Mono happens, even to 64-year-olds.

The Author

Patty Newbold is a widow who got it right the second time...

Follow Us

Enjoy Being Married

Grow Your Marriage Award 2011 from The Generous Wife
2011 Hot Marriage Blog Award © Liufu Yu |


Creative Commons License

This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.
TM Assume Love is trademark of Patricia L. Newbold